So Proudly We Hail (1943): A Classic Movie Review

So Proudly We Hail (1943) starring Claudette Colbert

Claudette Colbert, Paulette Goddard and Veronica Lake. These three very different Paramount Pictures actresses were brought together to star in one of my favorite 1940s films, So Proudly We Hail (1943). The film follows a pair of U.S. Army nurses–Lt. Janet Davidson (Colbert) and Lt. Joan O’Doul (Goddard)–who leave for Hawaii to begin their tour of duty. Shortly after they leave, Pearl Harbor is attacked and the United States is brought into World War II. The military ship picks up nurses and wounded from Pearl Harbor, among them troubled nurse Lt. Olivia D’Arcy (Lake). The trio is then sent to the Philippines, first assisting soldiers in Bataan and then evacuating to Corregidor.

From a dramatization of Doolittle’s Raid in Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo to Mrs. Miniver showing life on the British homefront and the Battle of Dunkirk, WWII-era Hollywood made several films that depicted what was going on overseas at the time. While I enjoy most ’40s WWII films, I love So Proudly We Hail because of its focus on military nurses.

Colbert is the real star of the film; the rock of the group of nurses, leading them to aid injured soldiers. Goddard and Lake flank her as secondary female leads: Goddard the flirty, glamor girl and Lake the troubled, quiet nurse. Their differences in real life as actresses, as well as the differences in their characters, illustrate the wide range of people who were brought in to serve together during wartime.

“The events in this movie were still very much on the minds of Americans when this film came out,” said Turner Classic Movies prime time host Robert Osborne in the DVD introduction. “Events in the movie had happened for real recently and news reports were still coming out.” Movies like this are made to make viewers feel proud and patriotic of their country, but what I like about So Proudly We Hail is that I feel it’s fairly realistic. Nurses with 104-degree temperatures from malaria are still caring for men while others are craving tomatoes and milk, items that can’t be found on the military front.

“What is a heroine,” One nurse asks, tired of all the attention on their voyage home. “I don’t know. Anyone who is still alive,” another says.

While Colbert is consistently good in all of her films, So Proudly We Hail gave Lake and Goddard the chance to show off their acting chops.

One scene that sticks out is when Goddard and Colbert find out why Lake acts cold towards the other nurses. She opens up to Colbert about why she is angry and is there to “kill Japs”: “Today is Christmas, isn’t it? The time for cheer and good fellowship and for peace. Well, today’s my wedding day. He and I were to be married today in St. Louis. And why weren’t we? Because he’s dead. He died that first morning. They killed him. I saw him. He was running across the field to his plane and they killed him. Sixty bullets – sixty! By the time I got to him he was dead. His face was gone – I couldn’t see him anymore. Just blood – blood all over.”

For Goddard, the scene that stays with you is when she tearfully says goodbye to soldiers in a military hospital before being shipped back to the United States. When the film starts, Goddard is flirty, saying she has two fiancés, because she can’t say no to an engagement. But throughout the film, as she sees the horrors of war, she wants to help in every way she can, attending to soldiers and never sleeping. At the end she gives the wounded soldiers small gifts of hers and her old love letters for some laughs.

So Proudly We Hail Movie PosterOther scenes that stick out to me:

• When Pearl Harbor is attacked, the nurses and military personnel are on a boat several miles out watching the bombing. There are screams of horror and disbelief as they, helplessly, watch the attack.

• Lt. O’Doul (Goddard) wearing a lacy black nightgown throughout the film. The nightgown first enters as a dress for the Christmas party. Later she wears it every night to keep her morale up.

• The son of Nurse Capt. “Ma” McGregor has his legs amputated and soon after dies. Her son never knew his father, because he died in battle, and now Ma’s grandson won’t know his father, either.

 • The scene when the nurses are left behind during an evacuation. The nurses are the last to ship out during evacuation as the Japanese move closer. Lt. O’Doul forgets her nightgown, holding their truck up, and the male drivers are shot. As Lt. Davidson (Colbert) searches for the truck keys to drive them out, the nurses panic.

• During this scene is when Lt. D’Arcy dies. She takes a grenade, pulls out the pin, puts it in her uniform and walks towards the Japanese pretending to surrender. She dies to protect her peers and to “kill Japs,” which is what she originally said she wanted to do. The scene is horrifying and shocking for a 1940s film.

• When the Japanese bomb the military hospital, sweet nurse Lt. Rosemary Larson (Barbara Britton) is killed when the roof of the hospital collapses.

• When Lt. Davidson and Lt. Summers (George Reeves) get married and are given gifts of bread and peanut butter. Another sign of how much items we take for granted were valued.

The movie also has two romances: A playful and joking one between Paulette Goddard and a marine played by Sonny Tufts, and a more serious, passionate one with Claudette Colbert and a soldier played by George Reeves. However, I don’t feel the relationship takes away from the true purpose of the film. 

As mentioned before, the three actresses were very different, and it has been rumored that they didn’t get along. “All three were popular actresses and not accustomed to sharing close-ups,” Osborne said. In Veronica Lake’s autobiography, she said she got along with her co-stars while it was Colbert and Goddard who locked horns. However, actor Reeves disagreed. “George Reeves said Veronica was the difficult one,” Osborne said. “Claudette was the morale builder for the whole cast, and if there was a problem it was because all three were so different. Reeves said it takes three to make a quarrel and Colbert wasn’t into that. She was too busy doing her work.”

Comet Over Hollywood, named for the 1938 Kay Francis film Comet Over Broadway, offers anything from Hollywood beauty tips to rants about Katherine Hepburn. Jessica Pickens is a journalism student at Winthrop University who is interested in silent films to anything made before 1964. She writes for Winthrop’s student newspaper, The Johnsonian, and the Shelby Star in Shelby North Carolina. Visit her Facebook page. 

  • barbara moss

    This is a great synapsis and breakdown of the important points of both the horrors of war, the transformation along life’s journey, and the impact it has on how women had to survive the internal pain and losses. It is a wonderful movie with a great script, (listen to the words)
    that exhibits women in all aspects of a complex personality during war time, breaking down the stereotypes of what women can and can’t do. The fact that they were all on some level, studio prima-dona’s thrown together to work it out, gave it the edgy tension developed within each character. Authentic and unusual for 3 heavy hitter actresses, although Colbert could carry herself into any role with major impact on any level. She was a multi-talented actress and the studio served her up well in supporting her talent.

    I appreciated this review.

    bmoss

  • Captrr

    Excellent review. I saw this movie long ago…and need to watch TCM’s schedule for another broadcast. I did remember the “dippity do girl,” Veronica Lake’s final scene. Having only seen her in “This Gun For Hire” it made quite an impression on me.

  • Al

    Good review of a classic war film. Colbert was always brilliant and Goddard was delightful in the film (She would have made a great Scarlet O’Hara).
    Even Lake was ok though wooden as always.

  • John M

    This movie was definitely well made with great precision and detail. It captures the different personalities of the brave nurses and how they handle the fears and emotions generated by the unpredictable situations of war. The review is extremely well done.

  • Cara

    I watched this just the other night on TCM after reading your review. I was so glad I endured it, and some of it was truly hard to watch. The incomparable Claudette Colbert was at the top of her game, and it was rewarding to watch a movie about the brave women in WWII. I have to admit, however, that I never was able to pin down which character Veronica Lake played. Maybe she was a better actress than many critics believed.