Vintage Years

Peter BogdonovichGuest blogger The Lady Eve writes:

The notion that 1939 was the greatest of all movie years has been around for so long that it’s pretty much an accepted fact these days. A while ago, as I was roaming the blogosphere, I happened upon a post by Peter Bogdanovich on his Indiewire blog (appropriately called Blogdanovich) titled “The Greatest Year?” I read on, having always respected what Mr. B has to say about films and filmmaking. He not only possesses an encyclopedic knowledge and intimate understanding of the subject, but has also made some classics of his own that I much admire – The Last Picture Show (1971), What’s Up, Doc? (1972) and Paper Moon (1973).

With “The Greatest Year?” Bogdanovich looked back on one of his 1972 columns for Esquire magazine. In that article he’d selected and reviewed a great movie year of the past to illustrate his contention that films of the early ’70s weren’t measuring up. He zeroed in on 1939 in particular because–in addition to the fact that it had been a banner year for movies–it was also the year he was born (as were Francis Ford Coppola and William Friedkin, two other major filmmakers of the time). Not long after Bogdanovich’s column appeared in Esquire, he recalled, a lengthier, more elaborate piece written by film critic Richard Schickel on the films of 1939 appeared in Life magazine . Schickel once and for all declared ’39 to be the great year. The rest, as we know, is history.

Peter Bogdanovich admitted in his Blogdanovich post that he actually believes “the absolute high point” of American film (he prefers the term ‘cinema’) encompasses 1939, 1940 and 1941. He has a point. 1940, too, was notable for a raft of classics. Here is one man’s tribute, via his YouTube channel, to some of the year’s best films:

YouTube Preview Image

Other of 1940’s offerings include Abe Lincoln in Illinois, The Letter, The Mortal Storm, Pride and Prejudice, and The Westerner, to name a few. 1941 was no less stellar, bringing Ball of Fire, (ahem) Citizen Kane, The Devil and Daniel Webster, High Sierra, How Green Was My Valley, The Lady Eve, The Little Foxes, The Maltese Falcon, Meet John Doe, Sergeant York, Sullivan’s Travels, Suspicion, and more. Perhaps I’m less a purist or maybe just more democratic, but I’d extend Hollywood’s high point back in time to 1937. That year introduced The Awful Truth (still my favorite screwball), Captains Courageous, Dead End, Lost Horizon, and Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. I’d also add, on the other end, 1942, the moment just before World War II’s impact was fully felt in Hollywood. 1942, after all, was the year of Casablanca, The Magnificent Ambersons, Now, Voyager, The Palm Beach Story, This Gun for Hire, To Be or Not to Be, Woman of the Year, and Yankee Doodle Dandy. 1937 – 1942 were all vintage years in Hollywood.

Here’s what Peter Bogdanovich originally wrote for Esquire in 1972, courtesy of critic/author Clive James’s website: The Best American Films of 1939.

It may seem ironic that Bogdanovich was disheartened by what he called “the meager pickings” of his own era, a time now viewed as another golden age. “The New Hollywood” had arrived and international cinema was in full blossom. 1972 alone saw the release of Fosse’s Cabaret, Bergman’s Cries and Whispers, Boorman’s Deliverance, Bunuel’s The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie and the film many consider the greatest of all, Francis Coppola’s The Godfather – not to mention Bogdanovich’s own very popular and award-winning What’s Up, Doc?

Parenthetically, 1972 would be the year Joseph Mankiewicz directed his last film. Sleuth, starring Laurence Olivier and Michael Caine, was nominated for four Academy Awards, including Best Director. With this final effort, Mankiewicz became one of few filmmakers who enjoyed success in both the old Hollywood and the new. The second Oscar nomination of his career (he won four and was nominated for eight) had been a Best Picture nod for producing MGM’s The Philadelphia Story in 1940.

What do you think the greatest year ever for movies was? Let us know in the comments!

The Lady Eve lives in Northern California and works in TV. Her blog posts have won CiMBA Awards from the Classic Movie Blog Association and been reprinted in newspapers and magazines. For more information, visit