When Irish Eyes Are Smiling on the Silver Screen

The Quiet Man (1952)

As I have stated before, I watch many different movies for many different reasons or holidays. My choice for St Patrick’s Day, however, is obviously very predictable.  

The Quiet Man, being my favorite film, is my staple. God, how I love that film. I actually watch it a couple of times during the year, as it’s a superb mood lifter. It’s also a movie I personally think–no, feel–is the most perfect casting of all!  I could not picture anybody else playing any of those roles other than the originals. I will be humming the Barry Fitzgerald “ dum dum, dum dum, dum dum, diddle diddle dum dum” ditty for days afterward.     

This is a movie rife with quotes: “here’s a nice stick to beat the lovely lady with”, or Fitzgerald’s “go to the pub to talk a little treason”, “when I drink water I drink water”, or “Homeric.” Why Barry was not nominated in a Best Supporting Actor Academy Award I’ll never know (no offense, Anthony)!

Well, once again I’ve gone off on a tangent, there are many other fine movies for this holiday which I’m sure you are all aware of. My personal second is The Luck of the Irish with Oscar-nominated Cecil Kellaway as Horace the leprechaun. Maybe if he did a jig like Walter Huston he would have won the award! It took me years as a child to finally tell the difference between Mr. Kellaway and Edmund Gwenn. I now know one is for St. Patty’s Day, the other for Christmas.  

Another more obscure favorite of mine is a made-for-TV movie, Finnegan Begin Again, with “gets better with age” actor Robert Preston and Mary Tyler Moore. The latter two films I have on VHS, since they have not come out on DVD.  I will round out the holiday with Ryan’s Daughter (with Robert Mitchum in a very different type of role), and A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, courtesy of James Dunn’s fine performance.

I will close by wishing you all “Saol Fada Chugat,” and don’t eat too much corned beef…leave some for the hash!

Bill Dunphy enjoys photography, cooking, reading, and, of course, movies–of which he has about 350 in his library.

  • Wayne P.

    Little Nellie Kelly, made in 1940, is a great and often overlooked dramatic, musical period piece with some comedic moments and sad scenes too! It starred a young and talented Judy Garland (in a dual role), George Murphy, and the wonderful Irish character actor Charles Winninger. The songs are fabulous and the story is very touching. Also, I like, in no particular order: The Great O’Malley, a fab Irish beat cop movie starring Pat O’Brien. And, last but not least, are the two great Irish priest Father O’Malley (no relation to the above;) picures from 1944 and ’45: Going My Way, plus its follow-up The Bells of St. Marys…with the wonderful duo of Bing Crosby and Barry Fitzgerald (who both won Oscars for their roles) in the former and Bing along with Ingrid Berman in the sequel. The music and storylines are top-notch. For suspense, you cant do much better than John Fords 1935 classic The Informer and we all probably love his The Quiet Man as well! Finally, a tip of the hat to Father Flanagan (a real life hero to orphaned boys) as portrayed by Spencer Tracy, and for which he won an Oscar for his performance, in Boys Town and its equally good next movie, Men of Boys Town…of course, I am working under the assumption that Tracys character is actually Irish! But, as the films are both set near Omaha, Nebraska…then its always possible hes not…but its fun to think of him that way for purposes of this piece since hes always in fine acting form wherever the person whos part hes playing is from!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Steven-Damm/631807641 Steven Damm

    I agree with Wayne – Little Nellie Kelly with Judy Garland is my favorite Irish movie. Begins in Ireland and ends in the USA. 3 great Irish songs – It’s a Great Day for the Irish, Danny Boy, and A Pretty Girl Milking Her Cow (sung partly in Irish-Gaelic) as well as the magnificent Singing In the Rain. Judy shines in this movie as does all of her cast members.

  • B.F.

    A real Irish gem by John Ford is ” The Rising of the Moon “, narrated in part by Tyrone Power – a trilogy of tales that does not get any better than this !!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Carolyn-Ferrante/100000671220210 Carolyn Ferrante

    I recently viewed, for the first time, on TCM “Jack Cassidy” (I think that was the title), starring the underrated actor Rod Taylor, Maggie Smith and a young Julie Christie.. It was the story of the playwright Sean O’Casey (hope I got that right). I sat mesmerized for the whole time, but the host of TCM claimed that the movie was not a box office hit.