Gaslight (1944): Classic Movie Review

Gaslight (1944) the 1944 mystery-thriller starring Ingrid Bergman(There may be spoilers in this post.)

What man would choose jewels over Ingrid Bergman? Liberace does not count…

Director George Cukor’s Gaslight (1944) is a taut drama filled with suspense and anxiety. Blessed by a spectacular cast of Hollywood heavyweights, Cukor, with the help of MGM’s suppression team, totally eclipsed the 1940 British film version of Patrick Hamilton’s play Gas Light, which was called Angel Street on Broadway. Nominated for seven Academy Awards, Gaslight is an excellent example of what a tight script, good acting, and superb art direction can do to create a truly memorable movie.

Screenwriters John Van Durten, Walter Reisch, and John L. Balderston’s adapted screenplay tells the story of Paula Alquist Anton (Ingrid Bergman), a young bride driven to believe she’s going insane by her manipulative, murderous husband Gregory (Charles Boyer). It is a dark tale of one man’s obsession with finding Paula’s aunt’s jewels at any cost. What I most admire about the story is that you don’t know exactly what Gregory is up to until the last 20 minutes of the film. Is Paula really going insane, or is Gregory “gaslighting” her? Gaslight is one of those films that, when you see it for a second time, you pick up on all the clues that point to Gregory’s true intentions. I’m not sure this is exactly a good thing, because some people might get miffed when the clues aren’t as obvious the first time they watch. Personally, it doesn’t bother me because I like suspense films that aren’t so clear-cut that you can figure out the mystery in the first 20 minutes.

Who better to play a fresh, young bride driven to the brink of insanity than Bergman—with her angelic beauty and sweet temperament (mind you, this was pre-Rossellini)? Bergman was so enthralled by the Broadway play that she lobbied her Hollywood captor, David O. Selznick, to loan her out to MGM so that she could play the part of Paula. Whatever poor Ingrid had to do to convince Selznick paid off, as she won her first Best Actress Academy Award for her searing performance. As someone who has watched first-hand as someone goes off the deep end, I have to say that Bergman’s fluctuations between rational and irrational behavior are spot on. When a person starts to believe that they are losing their grip on reality they fluctuate between extremes. The best example of this is when Paula confidently decides she is going to the music recital. Once there she is tricked into believing that she has stolen Gregory’s watch and bursts into hysterical tears.

Boyer plays his suave conniving part well, too. It took a lot of restraint not to play Gregory too darkly, as this would have hindered the suspense of the story. Instead, Boyer straddles the line between being a concerned husband and a ruthless manipulator. Personally, I would have liked to have seen him be a bit more menacing at the end of the film, because it would have added credibility to the idea that he’d strangled Paula’s aunt to death years before.

And then there’s an 18-year-old Angela Lansbury, playing the couple’s impertinent maid Nancy in her film debut. If her Cockney accent doesn’t surprise you, then the saucy way she plays the flirtatious maid will. What a way to start a career—giving Bergman dirty looks and engaging in light-sexual banter with Boyer. Cukor said that from Lansbury’s first day on the set it was obvious that she was a born actress. She earned a Best Supporting Actress Oscar nomination for a part that was supposed to be quite small, but Cukor had it expanded when he saw her acting potential.

Joseph Cotton and Dame May Whitty fill out the rest of the cast. While Cotton’s Brian Cameron plays an integral part at the conclusion, his role is a rather minor one. Whitty, for her part, plays the stereotypical nosy neighbor Ms. Thwaites. I’m not exactly sure what purpose she serves other than mild comic relief. Still, as with any Cotton or Whitty performance, they make their presences known.

Finally, I would be remiss if I didn’t mention the Oscar-winning black-and-white art direction of Cedric Gibbons, William Ferrari, Edwin Willis, and Paul Huldschinsky. The plot is Gothic in tone and dressed in Victorian décor, which creates a cluttered, creepy essence. Their use of fog to literally and metaphorically mask Gregory’s shady behavior is inspired, and their set decorations—especially the over-decorated home—are wonderfully thought out, too.

Overall, Ingrid Bergman’s strong performance and the engaging script are the main reasons I enjoyed Gaslight. Still, the vagueness of Gregory’s intentions could be off-putting to some. And, while cinematographer Joseph Ruttenberg earned an Academy Award nomination for his work, I believe the film falls a bit short when it comes to its overall photography.

Kim Wilson is a history professor and the author of the 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die blog.

  • Wayne P.

    Theyre both good but I thought the English version was underrated when you compared it to Gaslight…fine piece though and to each his own (favorite;) we should say!

  • Juanita Curtis

    one of my favourite suspense movies – 1ngrid Bergman deservedly won an oscar for her portrayal of Paula. Charles Boyer was also excellent. Recently saw Angela Lansbury on stage in Australia discussing her films – hard to believe she was only 18 when she made this!!!

  • John M

    This is the one film in which Ingrid Bergman looked her best and acted her best especially the climax scene in the attic.

  • FalmouthBill

    Even though I have my own copy of this fine movie, if it’s on TCM, .. I’m hooked, again ! I have an affinity for British movies, especially from this era, similar moods to another Ingrid movie from this era, Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde, her abuse runs rampant. I don’t mind colorization in certain cases, but, the above mentioned two films don’t apply, fog in a color movie doesn’t work [comes out blue, as in Phantom of the Opera{ Rains version}, and House of Wax ] !

  • katny

    “her Hollywood captor, David O. Selznick”
    brilliant.

  • Gayle Feyrer

    Love this movie!

  • roger lynn

    Bergman was great in this film,but her Oscar for it was not Barbara Stanwyck should of won for DOUBLE INDEMNITY

  • jan

    One of my all time favorites. The acting by all was wonderful and so believable. To me, Boyer’s acting throughout the movie was spot on. The lack of menacing behavior at the end of the movie make the evil in his action throughout the film stand out more. I have to admit – I have worn out several copies of this great movie.

  • jshay

    Good review of a great film, but it’s Joseph Cotten.