The Seven Best Classic TV Doctors

In today’s guest post, Rick29 writes in with his picks for the best TV doctors:

Change of seasons creating havoc with your allergies? Sprained an ankle from stepping in a rabbit hole while mowing (been there, done that)? Job stress causing migraines? You need to see a doctor!

To assist you in selecting the proper physician, we pick our classic TV favorites from the 1960s through the ’80s. Whether you want a brain surgeon, a family practitioner, or you’re just interested in a good-looking bachelor, the right M.D. awaits you:

1. Captain Benjamin Franklin “Hawkeye” Pierce (Alan Alda) – Sarcasm and wit mask the inner feelings of a deeply compassionate surgeon who can operate under the worst of conditions. Often consults with his friend “Trapper” John McIntyre, who has a successful private practice later in life.

2. Dr. James Kildare (Richard Chamberlain) – Long before Grey’s Anatomy’s McDreamy and McSteamy, Kildare ruled the airwaves as TV’s first heart-throb doctor in the 1960s. But don’t let his good looks fool you–he’s intelligent and caring. Plus, if you pay an office visit to him, you can get a second opinion from Blair Hospital’s senior M.D., Dr. Leonard Gillespie (Raymond Massey).

3. Dr. Richard Kimble (David Janssen) – Hey, you’re thinking, he’s on the run from the law on The Fugitive! That’s true, but he was wrongly convicted. He’s also very sensitive, has a way with kids (he was a pediatrician), and still appears to be current on the latest medical procedures.

4. Dr. Cliff Huxtable (Bill Cosby) – Looking for an obstetrician who accepts new patients? Then, try Dr. Huxtable…if you live in New York. In addition to having a good reputation as a doctor, he’s funny and also great with kids! Furthermore, if you’re the victim of malpractice (from another physician, of course), you can hire Cliff’s wife Clair as your attorney.

5. Dr. Marcus Welby (Robert Young) – No physician has a better bedside manner than the kindly, fatherly Dr. Welby. He always goes the extra step for his patients. An added bonus is his hip young partner, Dr. Kiley (James Brolin), who can get through to the new generation.

6. Dr. Ben Casey (Vince Edwards) – This intense, idealistic surgeon needs to tone it down from time to time, but everyone says he’s brilliant. It also helps that Dr. Zorba (Sam Jaffe) is around to provide a calming influence on the young Casey–and to offer second opinions.

7. Dr. Adam “Doc” Bricker (Bernie Kopell) – If you’re sick or injured on a luxury liner, then Doc Bricker is your man. Be forewarned, though; he does consider himself a ladies’ man and he doesn’t spend a lot of time attending to patients.

Honorable Mentions: Dr. Joe Gannon (Chad Everett) from Medical Center; the staff of Boston’s St. Eligius Hospital (aka St. Elsewhere); and Dr. Alex Stone (Carl Betz) from The Donna Reed Show. I’m sure I missed others, too, so please leave a comment if desired.

Rick29 is a film reference book author and a regular contributor at the Classic Film & TV Café , on Facebook and Twitter. He’s a big fan of MovieFanFare, too, of course!

  • Broadwayfan

    As a ‘group vote’ I put before you the doctors of County General in Chicago. “ER” had brilliant doctors, who made quick and amazing  decisions to save lives. They didn’t save them all, which was realistic. But, at 11 PM every Thursday night I was exhausted. Felt like I’d been running through those halls and working on those patients. Doctors would leave, new doctors would come. But the quality never faltered.

  • Wayne P.

    Great list and have always thought the show St. Elsewhere to be very intriguing and a different take on the institutional practice of medicine compared with almost every other ’good Dr.’ show on TV!

  • Kentgravett

    From way, way back–

    “The Medic” with Richard Boone, one of the very first serious and clear dramas of the genre. Always worked.

    • Pamhandle

      I don’t remember this show so I am going to look it up. I do enjoy Richard Boone and always watched “Have Gun, Will Travel”.

      • Kearneysm2

        The theme song of this show “Blue Star”, was on the Top Ten at that time. I loved that
        show.

        • FalmouthBill

          Richard Boone played Dr. Conrad Steiner on Medic, but he was in many cases just the narrator of that anthology series, they had many other actors in the actual stories ! 

      • hypatiab7

        It’s just called “Medic” , not “The Medic”

  • Brygolf

    dr. casey  for sure

  • Vinny Castellano

    How about Doc from Gunsmoke ?  - wise, principled, honest, courageous.  He was a key factor in making Gunsmoke the great western it was and still is.

  • ANH

    Quincy, M.E.(Jack Klugman)
    Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman (Jane Seymour)
    Dr. Brock, Picket Fences (Kathy Baker) 

    • Pamhandle

      Quincy was one of my favorites. But sadly to say, by the time you saw him it was to find out why you died and to prevent others from dying the same way. He was a crusader. Just loved the show.

      • KarenG_958

        Yes, Dr. Quincy, ME,  One of my favorite doctors, but not one you’d want to go to.

  • ANH

    And – lest we forget, that wonderful pediatrician,

    Dr. Harry Weston, Empty Nest (Richard Mulligan)

    • Pamhandle

      Loved the show and totally enjoyed his nurse.

  • OZ ROB

    How about that bewildered psychiatrist Dr Bellows ( Hayden Rorke ), I Dream of Jeannie ran from 1965 and had five successful seasons with 139 episodes finishing up in 1970,,

  • dog888k

    Dr. Bombay (or is it Mumbai now?) of Bewitched.  And the fake doctor (Hal March) Ricky brought in to convince Lucy she had the Gobloots in her zorch from the Booshoo bird. And Dr. Grannie Clampett with her bucketfull of tonic for healin.’

    • EM

      Glad to see that someone else remembers Liz Thorpe!

    • dog888k

      I had to look up the character’s name (from a show from the JFK era) even though I did remember Shirl Conway.  Those tough one-syllable names (Liz, Shirl, The, Nurs-es. A lesson for aspiring authors.

  • Marty

    My favorite was Alan Alda’s Hawkeye and second, the entire cast from St. Elsewhere. No mention was made about Richard Boone’s Konrad Steiner in Medic. That was the grandfather of all future tv medical shows. David Janssen’s role as Dr. Richard Kimble was special.

  • OZ ROB

    Must not forget Jonathan Harris the cowardly, Dr Zachary Smith,,reluctant stowaway on the Jupiter 2 he was usually  at odds with the family and their mission but was a good friend to Will & Robot while Lost in Space…

  • Janet Smith

    Hawkeye was great but I loved Sydney Freemen too.

  • Joseph23006

    Richard Boone, before “Have Gun, Will Travel”,  The show was “Medic” or “The Medic”.  That was early 50′s.  He was a surgeon, and each show began with him looking directly at the audience and saying, (I hope I get this right) “The eye of an eagle, the heart of a lion, the hand of a woman.” indicating the talents needed to perform operations in order to save lives.

  • Markht

    You FORGOT Dr. Leonard “Bones” McCoy played be DeForest Kelley in STAR TREK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    He could cure ANYTHING — including silicone based life forms!  I’d like to see Drs. Welby or Kildare try THAT!!!!!!!!

  • Rebel Ed

    Dr. “Trapper” John McIntyre from the series “Trapper John, M. D.”  Though Wayne Rogers created the TV version on “M*A*S*H,” I far prefer Pernell Roberts interpitation. 

    • Mjkody

      “Gonzo”on the same series…..

  • Gagaba4

    Lionel Barrymore as Dr. Gillespie in original Dr. Kildare film.

    • Wayne P.

      With very capable assists from Lew Ayres and Laraine Day and they made over ten films together but am not sure they were on the TV shows as havent seem them, but would like to!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Matt-Gaffney/1450547336 Matt Gaffney

    Doc from Gunsmoke.

  • Shadow0109

    Dr. Galen Adams (Milburn Stone) in “Gunsmoke”.

    • hypatiab7

      Great choices. My favorite is Leonard ‘Bones’ McCoy, but I’ve always liked Doc Adams.

  • Cat

    “Emergency” and Dr. Kelly Brackett (Robert Fuller).  He didn’t get as much “on screen presence,” but he certainly was a “PRESENCE,” especially where “on the sceen accident care” was concerned.

    • Vinny Castellano

      Thanks for remembering Dr. Brackett and Emergency.  I loved Emergency.  It was ahead of its time.  LA County had paramedic units back in 1974, and the show was a tribute to them.  The whole group exemplified teamwork and camaraderie.  As you mentioned, Dr. Brackett didn’t get much air time, but he played an integral part in the show.  Everyone pitched in, from the firefighters and paramedics – Gage and DeSoto et al – to the doctors and nurses in the hospital.   … great inspiring show!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/R2SCF5CNSK5LS7EEV62V66EZTU alanf

    Dr. Cox from Scrubs!!!!!!!!!

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/3IZG5BR7UJ3BWLQRKFIVTZMXBA JohnQ

    You say,”Captain Benjamin Franklin “Hawkeye” Pierce (Alan Alda)”. I say, no. no. no. He is just a big a?? with the most phony laugh ever produced.

    • hypatiab7

      I wonder if all the doctor actors you do like are Republicans.

      • SoonerAlfie

        Just because the guy doesn’t like old “Hawkeye?”  Off topic, pal …

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OC6SKJLQDZEY674X7VRYBWH6AI Tom

    ” And when Ben Casey met Kildare they called it a ” paradox ‘ “.

  • LPC13

    Richard Boone as “Medic”, the pioneer of the genre.

  • Bettyroman2

    Though not a fan of the show, I do like Patrick Dempsey…..as McDreamy!!!!!

  • Mike

    HOUSE is my wifes favorite, and mine is QUINCY.

  • Pacerdad

    I loved “Quincy” with Jack Klugman.  What about Dr. Frasier Crane on “Frasier”??  Does that count?  And his brother Dr. Niles Crane.

  • dog888k

    Theodoric of York–Medieval Barber. who was always bleeding someone hung upside down.
    Dr. Ben Casement (who was a plumber) sent Fred and Barney to Frantic City for R&R.

  • Lacewing_3

    Quincy

  • Carol Chambo

    Dr. Cal Brackett ( Emergency- Robert Fuller)  and my moms fav Dr. Quincy Medical Examiner

  • Cap’n Marvel

    What about Doc Adams. He patched up more with less in Dodge City.

  • Jjglong

    Mark Greene – ER

  • Greg

    How about Dr. Conrad Steiner (Richard Boone) Medic

  • Gaedi7

    House is the best! Lou

  • Roland

    It’s Tom Baker AKA Doctor Who!

  • JerseyJoe

    One correction for you, Rick29. Dr. Cliff Huxtable lived in Philly, not NY.

  • Peter

    My favorite is a Brit and he’s a vet— Dr. James Herriott of “All Creatures Great and Small”.

  • Larry

    Are you sexist?  What about Dr. Quinn (Jane Seymour) Medicine Woman?

  • Beatlegirls25

    Yes, definitely Dr. Quinn should be up there!  What about Doc, acted by Billy Ray Cyrus?  Thought it was a great show.

    • Luvthe7ts

      Excellent, excellent show. 

  • Go2jill

    And of course the antithesis of them all, Charles Emerson Winchester III.

  • Beatlegirls25

    Oh yeah, what about Dr. Brennan from Bones?

  • http://www.facebook.com/rose.anderson.52 Rose Anderson

    I can remember wearing a Ben Casey shirt to school — they were all the rage maybe when I was in 6th grade.  I was soooo cool!!  No one will ever replace Richard Chamberlain as the dreamiest doctor, but Marcus Welby + James Brolin got the best of care and dreaminess!

  • Maria

    Yay!  I was always in love with Dr. Kildare.  Richard Chamberlain played the part well.  I wish there were reruns I could watch.  It was always “team” Kildare or Ben Casey back then!

    • Maria

      Excuse me for replying to myself.  But how can you not love Alan Alda as Hawkeye Pierce????

      • Wayne P.

        I dunno…why dont you reply to yourself again and ask yourself?!  :)

  • fogelmama

    Nobody but me remembers Richard Boone as Konrad Styner, MD in Medic?
    He was my favorite doc until I met the one I married.

  • Pandypoop

    Ok where is Dr Who! The world would have been destroyed several times over without Dr Who!

    • Guest

      Doctor Who was his name not his profession.

  • Mikel6528

    What about “Doc” Holiday? Just kidding. So many to choose. I like “Dr. House” …”House” the show, “medically” always made you think… (Dr. Cuddy was annoying :)  …also like Ben Casey ( I only saw it in late night reruns, but I always liked it). 

  • CaptCutshaw

    Darn you, Pandypoop, you beat me to it! Here The world and the whole universe would have been destroyed many times without Dr. Who. I was all ready to lend my support to Tom Baker. :-)

  • Alan Stageberg

    How about Dr. Ben Casey….or have all his patients died by now?  Who could forget his wild-haired mentor, Dr. Zorba?

  • Steve Simon

    Quincy M.E. (Jack Klugman) foreshadowed current crime shows.

  • Sarathompson

    aai also agree with the choices that are listed.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1111

  • Luvthe7ts

    I put Dr. Joe Gannon on the top of the list. But then Marcus Welby.

  • Luvthe7ts

    Sorry I forgot about Quincy.  He was high up on the list as well.

  • Rpharmon767@gmail.com

    Trapper John md with Gonzo

  • tenther1

    I guess I’m showing my age, but I join fogelmama in remembering Richard Boone as Dr. Konrad Styner in “Medic” I was so young, though, and I had a such a phobia about hospitals that I used to run out of the room when I heard the creepy theme music. 

  • Bamaborne

    You forgot

    Trapper John McIntyre and Dr. Gonzo Gates (Trapper John M.D.)

    Dr Quincy ( Quincy)

  • dog888k

    Dr. Zarkov who watched over Flash Gordon,and had a neat beard. And Dr. Archie Campbell on Hee Haw, who could not keep from watching Nurse Goodbody (but who could?) 

  • Fabiansutcliffe

     I agree with the top 2 choices without a doubt! Although, I’ve would’ve had Dr. Quincy at No. 3.

  • Edie04freedom

    You forgot Trapper John McIntyre as portrayed by Pernell Roberts and Gonzo Gates as played by Gregory Harrison.

  • Frcp

    what not women?  how about Dr Quinn medicine woman or any of the lady doc on Grey’s

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Irene-Childs/1251752907 Irene Childs

    what about the Bold Ones

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Irene-Childs/1251752907 Irene Childs

    tempeartures rising in the 70′s 

  • Bullet190

    House is number 1 by far. You also missed Dr. Cox from Scrubs!

  • Hesiod

    Dr. “Bones” McCoy from Star Trek didn’t make the list. :-(

    • Slftrek

      Another GOOD ONE…”He’s dead Jim.”

  • Louis Copman

    Konrad Steiner, Doctor of Medicine, played by Richard Boone in the great 50′s show “Medic”

  • T_jenifer

    Dr Quin Medicine Woman

  • Thawkins1

    How about “Doc Adams” from Gunsmoke.

  • Carlene

    i think Dr ben casey (vince edwards) was the best best best !!  to me he is the ideal…
      second i liked chad everett in medical center.. oh those were the best days of TV…

    in more recent times….. billy ray cyrus was AWESOME on DOC as dr clint cassidy….

  • tracy frey

    how about marcus welby M.D. played by robert young from family know best. the son  billy gray was the kid in the day the earth stood still in 1951.

  • Jthurman74

    Doc Adams on Gunsmoke

  • Doc Reid

    Doc Galen Adams on Gunsmoke…a curmudgeon but always loveable!

  • Trosshill

    Doctor Adams of Dodge City and Gunsmoke! Best TV Doctor of them all.

  • Sharon

    The young whipper snapper~  We agree that Hawkeye and trapper are among the best.  but the what about Wiburn Stone, as Doc Adams on Gunsmoke , or the Doc on “little House On the Praire” who spent his last days in our coummunity in Oregon assisting the local high School’s drama department. One our favorite current ones is  the doc on Murder She Wrote, and currently, Doc Martin, on PBS, which your friend Romney wants to do away with along with Big Bird! Yes I almost forgot Dr. Quinn!

    • Slftrek

      Yes to Doc Adams…also Dr. Quinn.

  • Vinny Castellano

    Has anyone mentioned Dr. Richard Kimble from the TV show – The Fugitive?  He was always on the run from the police after being falsely convicted of killing his wife; yet he remained loyal to his principles, helped other people, and pursued the one-armed man who committed the crime.  … great series starring David Jansen.  The movie from 1993 starring Harrison Ford was a great tribute to the original and well-acted and written.

  • Slftrek

    Hey you forgot Doc Adams from “Gunsmoke”, he was a favorite of mine.  Milburn Stone…

  • Slftrek

    And how about Dr. Quinn, the medicine woman…She faced a lot of pregidice as a woman doctor.

  • Wojtek

    Doc Adams on “Gunsmoke” the best ever with primitive equipment. “Bite on the bullet”. 18 years on TV or 20.

  • Sistergrimm

    I go w-a-a-a-y back, to . . . Ramar of the Jungle!  Dr. Tom “Ramar” Reynolds,  jungle physician, non pareil from 1952  to 1954 and re-runs for years and years on TV in L.A.

  • Dog888k

    Dr. Katz!

  • Ganderson

    What?  No Dr. Bob from “Veterinarian’s Hospital” on the old Muppet Show?  I loved the closing scene when the good doctor and his nurses would look around in confusion at the mysterious voice of a narrator saying, “tune in next time when we’ll hear Dr. Bob say . . . “

  • The Blue Carbuncle

    How about Bob Newhart ?  and let’s not forget Chief Medical Officer Leonard McCoy, USS Enterprise

  • dog888k

    Back in the 50s radio soapopera heartthrob Young Doctor Malone was on TV. Maybe someone remembers him 

  • dog888k

    I did some web research into Wyatt Earp and Tombstone Territory TV shows, and Wyatt Earp (with Hugh O’Brian) had Doc Holiday as a character, played by Myron Healey.  Looking into the cast of Tombstone Territory, none of the Earp gang was ever written into the show.    

  • dog888k

    Bobby Troup played Dr. Joe Early on Emergency. and Nurse Dixie McCall was none other than Julie London. Oh I wish Nurse Dixie could have healed me over and over.